Global Digital Assets Digest December 2024
16 December 2024
Welcome to this month's Global Digital Assets Digest. The big news this month is that certain aspects of MiCA and the Recast Wire Transfer Regulation become applicable in December 2024. There are rumblings that the deadline for MiCA may prove a bit tricky. Not surprisingly, a number of delegated acts under MICA have been finalised in the last month.
In the UK, the FCA has published its cryptomap and provided further details on the next steps for a regulatory regime.
In APAC, there's news from Hong Kong on a Stablecoins Bill and the Digital Bond Grant Scheme, while MAS gives us the latest on tokenisation in Singapore.
Stateside, there's a changing of the guard at one regulator, a development of significant impact for the cryptoassets industry.
Updates and Guidance: International Bodies
1. EU: Correspondence on interplay between MiCA and PSD2
2. ESAs: Final report on guidelines on explanations, opinions and standardised test for classifying cryptoassets under MiCA
3. ESMA: Joint EBA and ESMA Guidelines on the assessment of the suitability of the members of the management body of issuers and CASPs
4. EBA: Consultation paper on draft RTS for appointment of central contact points for CASPs under MLD4
5. ECB: Slides: The case for a digital euro in the European payments landscape
6. BIS: Paper: Central bank digital currencies and fast payment systems: rivals or partners?
7. MiCA: Commission Implementing Regulation on ITS on forms, formats and templates for cryptoasset white papers published in OJ
8. ESMA: Authorised DLT Market Infrastructures
9. ECB: Progress report on the digital euro
10. European Commission: Adoption of Delegated Regulation under MiCA covering RTS on the content and format of order book records for trading platforms
11. ECB: Norway joins TIPS, adding Norwegian krone to Eurosystem’s instant payment service
12. European Commission: Commission Delegated Regulation on regulatory technical standards relating to publication of transparency data by CASPs under MiCA
13. MiCA: Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2902 on reporting related to ARTs and certain EMTs
14. MiCA: Commission Implementing Regulation on forms, templates and procedures for the cooperation and exchange of information published in OJ
15. ECB: Eurosystem completes tests using DLT for central bank money settlement
16. Global Digital Finance: GDF Announces New Travel Rule VASP Working Group led by OKX and Other Global Crypto Exchanges
17. CGAP/BIS/IMF/UNSGSA/The World Bank: Report: Key Considerations for Open Finance
18. IOSCO: New Roadmap to enhance Retail Investor Online Safety
19. ESMA: Report on the assessment of the shortening of the settlement cycle in the EU
Updates and Guidance: UK
20. FCA: Next steps for regulation of cryptoassets
21. FCA: Policy statement: Financial Crime Guide Changes Feedback to CP24/9 and Final Guidance (PS 24/17)
22. BoE: Speech by Sasha Mills, Executive Director for Financial Market Infrastructures: Beyond Faster Horses: Wholesale Financial Markets in the Digital Age
23. HM Treasury: Speech by Tulip Siddiq, Economic Secretary to the Treasury: Tokenisation Summit: UK government approach to tokenisation and regulation
24.House of Lords (Property (Digital Assets etc) Bill [HL] Special Public Bill Committee): Call for Evidence: Property (Digital Assets etc) Bill
25. FMLC: Minutes: FMLC Committee Meeting 16 October 2024
26. FCA: Discussion Paper: Transaction reporting paper
Updates and Guidance: Europe
No new entries
Updates and Guidance: APAC
27. MAS: Remarks by Mr Lim Tuang Lee, Assistant Managing Director (Capital Markets) at the Futures Industry Association
28. Hong Kong Stablecoins Bill
29. HKEX: Virtual Asset Index Series
30. HKMA: Digital Bond Grant Scheme
Updates and Guidance: Australia
31. Australian Parliament: AML/CTF laws passed
32. ASIC: Consultation Paper 381: Updates to INFO 225: Digital Assets: Financial Products and Services
33. SEC: Arbitration, Alternative Assets, and Aging Actors: Remarks at the meeting of the SEC Investor Advisory Committee
34. SEC: Departure of Gary Gensler
35. House Committee on Financial Services: Hearing on financial innovation
36. CFTC’s Global Markets Advisory Committee advances Recommendation on Tokenised Non-cash collateral
37. House Financial Services Committee: Hearing on prudential banking regulators
38. Remarks by Assistant Secretary for International Finance Brent Neiman on the US Cross-Border Payments Agenda
On 10 December 2024, correspondence between the European Commission and EBA was published in relation to the interplay between PSD2 and MiCA.
MiCA notes a degree of overlap between cryptoasset services provided by CASPs under MiCA and payment services regulated under PSD2, particularly where this concerns certain services relating to EMTs. EMTs fall within the definition of funds under PSD2 and consequently have a dual nature i.e. they are cryptoassets under MiCA and are electronic money/funds within PSD2.
The Commission notes that CASPs providing payment services with EMTs will therefore need to either hold an authorisation as a PSP, or partner with an authorised PSP to provide certain payment services. According to the Commission, the provision of transfers of EMTs by CASPs may be considered as a payment service (execution of payment transactions), while cryptoasset services relating to EMTs could fall under points 1 and 2 of Annex I of PSD2 (operations required for operating a payment account).
The Commission calls for the EBA to consider issuing an opinion on the enforcement of the authorisation requirement in PSD2 where this concerns EMTs provided by CASPs (or by entities benefiting from the transitional period under Article 143(3) of MiCA).
The EBA confirms that it will publish its response by April 2025.
On 10 December 2024, the ESAs published a final report on guidelines designed to encourage consistency on the classification of cryptoassets under MiCA. The Guidelines include a standardised test, as well as templates market participants should use when communicating classification of a cryptoasset to supervisors.
The templates for explanations and legal opinions provide descriptions of the regulatory classification of cryptoassets in the following instances.
The guidelines will apply two months after the publication of their translation in all official languages of the EU.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 4 December 2024, ESMA published a webpage with links to the official translations of joint ESMA and EBA guidelines on suitability assessments.
MiCA requires members of the management body to be of sufficiently good repute and capable of committing sufficient time to effectively perform their duties. This includes an assessment of whether members of the management body have the appropriate knowledge (individually and collectively), skills and experience to perform their duties.
ESMA and the EBA published a final report on the joint guidelines in June 2024.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 4 December 2024, the EBA published a public consultation on draft RTS on the criteria used by CASPs to appoint a central contact point to ensure compliance with local AML/CFT obligations of the host Member State.
The Recast Wire Transfer Regulation amends MLD4 by extending to CASPs the provisions that Member States may require EMIs and PSPs established on their territory in forms other than a branch to appoint a CCP point in their territory.
The change to MLD4 will require updates to Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/1108. The EBA proposes to retain the structure and approach with new provisions introduced to reflect the business model of CASPs. This includes specific criteria for determining when as CCP should be appointed for CASPs. The EBA also notes that the notion of "establishment" is challenging from a practical perspective owing to the nature of some cryptoasset services (limited physical equipment needed for operators mainly providing services to customers through non-physical means).
The deadline for comments is 4 February 2025. The final report on draft regulatory technical standards is to be published in Q2, 2025.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 4 December 2024, the ECB published slides on the digital euro. Areas covered in the slides include the following: responding to a fast changing payments landscape; the impact of fragmentation and digitalisation on the euro area's strategic autonomy; the need to involve stakeholders in both the private and public sector in relation to work on the digital euro; and ways that the distribution of a digital euro via PSPs will help maintain customer relationships amid trend towards digital wallets.
On 3 December 2024, BIS published a paper titled "Central bank digital currencies and fast payment systems: rivals or partners?". The paper, which is the result of interviews with central banks in 14 jurisdictions, compares the features of retail CBDC and faster payment systems, offering insights into why some jurisdictions opt for a retail CBDC, while others have opted for FPS (or both). The paper concludes that choice between a retail CBDC or an FPS will depend on factors such as market features and the level of maturity and innovation of existing payment infrastructures.
On 3 December 2024, Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2984 setting out ITS on the forms, formats and templates for cryptoasset white papers under MiCA was published in the Official Journal of the EU This follows a final report on the draft ITS in July 2024.
MiCA requires white papers to contain information that is relevant to enable investors to make an informed investment decision and to be available in a machine-readable format. The aim of having standardised templates to report the information is to encourage transparency and comparability of white papers.
The Implementing Regulation comes into force on 23 December 2024 and will apply from 23 December 2025.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 3 December 2024, ESMA published a webpage in relation to authorised DLT market infrastructures. This sets out a list of DLT SSs and DLT TSSs.
On 2 December 2024, the ECB published a progress report in relation to the digital euro. The preparation phase outlines progress made during the preparation phase in respect of the digital euro between May and October 2024. The preparation phase of the project began in November 2023 and involves testing and experimentation, as well as regular exchanges with stakeholders.
Key actions cited in the report include:
Next steps include the following:
The ECB has also published a letter from Piero Cipollone, Member of the Executive Board, ECB, to Aurore Lalucq, ECON Chair, on the second progress report on the digital euro preparation phase.
On 29 November 2024, the European Commission adopted a Delegated Regulation on RTS in relation to the content and format of order book records. MiCA requires CASPs operating trading platforms for cryptoassets to keep records of all orders in cryptoassets and make these records available to the competent authorities. The data to be shared with competent authorities is to be recorded on JSON format based on ISO 20022 methodology;
Requirements imposed on cryptoasset trading platforms by the RTS include;
The Delegated Regulation will now be scrutinised by EU co-legislators. If neither objects, the Regulation will be published in the Official Journal of the EU.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 29 November 2024, the ECB confirmed that Norway had joined TARGET Instant Payment Settlement TIPS. This will result in the Nowegian krone being the fourth currency available for settlement in TIPS in addition to the euro, the Swedish krona and the Danish krone). This step forms part of the Eurosystem's TARGET Services planned for the first half of 2028.
On 28 November 2024, the European Commission adopted a Delegated Regulation (containing RTS specifying how CASPs operating a trading platform for cryptoassets are to present transparency data under MiCA. This follows a July 2024 final report.
Article 76 of MiCA sets out requirements in relation to requires trading platforms to make public pre-trade transparency requirements and post-trade transparency requirements. Among other things, the RTS set out the general principles of presentation of information on operating rules for trading platforms, as well as the requirements concerning the data disaggregation of pre-trade and post-trade data.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 28 November 2024, Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2902 on reporting related to ARTs and to EMTs denominated in a currency that is not an official currency of a Member State was published in the Official Journal.
MiCA requires issuers of ARTs and EMTs denominated in a non-EU currency to report specified information to the relevant competent authority on a quarterly basis. CASPs providing services related to ARTs must also provide issuers of ARTs with the information needed to prepare these reports. Article 58(3) of MiCA specifies that Article 22 applies to ARTs and EMTs denominated in a non-EU currency.
Areas covered by the ITS include requirements concerning:
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 26 November 2024, the Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2545 on standard forms, templates and procedures for the cooperation and exchange of information between competent authorities was published in the Official Journal. The purpose of the delegated act is to encourage information exchange between NCAs to enable the effective supervision of issuers and offerors of cryptoassets.
The Implementing Regulation comes into force on 16 December 2024.
For more on MiCA, please see our briefings here and here.
On 4 December 2024, the ECB provided further details in relation to tests carried out concerning the use of DLT for wholesale settlement in central bank money. The ECB confirms that 64 participants carried out over 40 trials and experiments. Lessons gained from the work will inform analysis on the opportunities and challenges presented by DLT for financial markets (including how to facilitate the provision of central bank money settlement for wholesale transactions of assets on DLT platforms).
On 22 November 2024, the Global Digital Finance announced the New Travel Rule VASP Working Group led by OKX and Other Global Crypto Exchanges. The project looks at challenges faced by VASPs in implementing the FATF Travel Rule. This will focus on developing best practices for VASPs; (screening protocols, requests for information, transaction returns, and exception handling); and supporting global regulatory engagement.
Comment: The Travel Rule was introduced in the UK in September 2023, with the FCA setting out expectations for UK CASPs. It was implemented in the EU via the Recast Wire Transfer Regulation, with the EBA issuing guidelines on detecting missing/incomplete information accompanying a transfer of funds/cryptoassets. These guidelines apply from 30 December 2024.
On 20 November 2024, the World Bank issued a report on high level considerations for financial sector authorities wishing to implement open finance. The report focuses on: open finance; sector wide arrangements; country level data sharing. It also sets out 10 key elements of an open finance framework. These include: objectives; process leadership; governance arrangements; regulation; oversight and supervision; consumer and data protection; and consumer information and awareness
On 19 November 2024, IOSCO published details of a roadmap focused on regulation, education and collaboration to tackle risks arising from technological developments. The Roadmap consists of five waves of targeted actions planned over the next 12 months.
Comment: The reports contain draft good practices for market participants active in this area. Final reports will follow the consultations and the Roadmap is an ongoing initiative. This is an area of increased regulatory scrutiny. ESMA has already published a discussion paper on the impact of digitalisation and the MiFID investor protection framework (see our briefing here), while the FCA has issued communications in this area. The results of IOSCO work will likely inform future FCA and ESMA work.
On 18 November 2024, ESMA published a Final Report on shortening the settlement cycle EU.
The report outlines benefits that a move to T+1 would bring (e.g. increased efficiency and resilience of post-trade processes) . ESMA recommends migration to T+1 simultaneously across all relevant instruments by Q4 2027, with 11 October 2027 as the optimal date for the transition to T+1 in the EU. A coordinated approach with other jurisdictions in Europe is also proposed.
ESMA notes that amendments will need to be made to the CSDR and the settlement discipline framework in order move successfully to T+1. It also states that coordination and standardisation efforts from market participants will be required.
ESMA is to continue its regulatory work on settlement efficiency, and T+1 governance with the European Commission and the ECB.
Comment: There have been various efforts in a number of jurisdictions to shorten the settlement cycle. Changes occurred in the US in May 2024. In the UK, the terms of reference for the taskforce on shortening the settlement cycle discussed the case for the UK moving to T+0 and eventually to atomic settlement/instantaneous settlement (noting the impact of blockchain and other technology).
On 26 November 2024, the FCA published three important publications on cryptoassets:
Key milestones set out by the FCA in relation to a regulatory for cryptoassets include:
For more information, please see our briefing here.
Comment: These publications provide clarity on the emerging legal and regulatory framework for cryptoassets in the UK. Importantly, the publications demonstrate that next year will be critical for cryptoassets firms operating, or wishing to operate, in the UK.
On 24 November 2024, the FCA published a Policy Statement containing feedback on proposed changes to its Financial Crime Guide following an earlier consultation. The Guide is sector agnostic and looks at financial crime controls and specific risks. The FCA explicitly confirms that the Guide applies to firms registered under the MLRs.
Self-assessment questions in the Guide include how to assess and address the risks of different types of cryptoassetst (e.g. anonymity-enhanced or privacy coins). Poor practice in relation to ongoing monitoring for customer due diligence includes: CASPs assuming that blockchain analysis alone is sufficient to monitor transactions and failing to do own transaction monitoring based on the knowledge of customers. Good practice for CASPs in relation to preventing loss from fraud includes pre-screening outbound transactions for addresses linked to fraud.
Comment: Firms may want to assess provisions in the Guide against pre-existing crime systems and controls/internal policies.
On 21 November 2024, the BoE published a speech by Sasha Mills, Executive Director for Financial Market Infrastructures, titled "Beyond Faster Horses: Wholesale Financial Markets in the Digital Age." This speech was delivered at the Tokenisation Summit and looked at the impact of programmable platforms and adoptions of new technologies on post trade processes and on the wider financial system.
On 21 November 2024, HMT published a speech by Tulip Siddiq, Economic Secretary to the Treasury. The speech outlines initiatives the UK government is taking forward such as the DSS and the wider cryptoasset strategy.
Key issues
Comment: After months of speculation and delay, this speech provides concrete information form the Government for firms on the direction of travel and expected publications in relation to the regulatory regime for cryptoassets.
The Special Public Bill Committee on the Property (Digital Assets etc) Bill has issued a call for evidence in respect of the Bill.
The Bill, which was introduced in the House of Lords in September 2024, clarifies that certain digital assets can be recognised as property, even where they do not fit into the two traditional categories of personal property in English and Welsh law. The Bill avoids stating the digital assets that are to fall within the “third category” of personal property rights or their legal treatment (these details will be developed by the courts on a case-by-case basis).
Questions posed by the call for evidence include: negative or unexpected consequences of the Bill; areas for improvement; and implications the Bill has for the development of common law in England and Wales (and in other legal jurisdictions).
The deadline for comments is 20 December 2024.
The FMLC has published the minutes of the FMLC Committee Meeting held on 16 October 2024. Topics for discussion included a letter form the FMLC setting out certain areas of uncertainty relating to the scope of the MLRs, as well as a draft paper on the financial services regulatory regime for cryptoassets setting out potential uncertainties.
The FCA published a discussion paper (DP 24/2) on the future of the transaction reporting regime under UK MiFIR. Among other areas, the discussion paper looks at the role the transaction reporting regime could play to support the development of new and existing technologies. The FCA also discusses how to monitor trading in tokenised securities more effectively (e.g. when trading is in a tokenised security or has a tokenised security as an underlying). Views are sought on adding new fields for the Digital Token Identifier (the global standard for identifying digital tokens) for the instrument and for the underlying in RTS 22. The field would be filled in when a tokenised security is traded or an instrument with a tokenised instrument as the underlying is trade.
Comment: ESMA's consultation paper on amendments to the EU transaction reporting regime as a result of MiFiR II also considered ways to enhance monitoring of trading in tokenised securities.
No new entries
On 4 December 2024, MAS published the keynote address by Mr Lim Tuang Lee, Assistant Managing Director (Capital Markets) MAS, delivered at the Futures Industry Association. The speech provided an overview of MAS' regulatory priorities in relation to capital markets and also touched on the transformative potential of DLT, as well as the importance of balancing robust regulation and active collaboration. The speech calls for more legal and regulatory certainty concerning how certain activities are treated in the blockchain and confirms that MAS has initiated a review of existing rules and regulations relating to the tokenisation of capital markets products. This review will look at existing regulatory barriers and may provide further industry guidance.
On 6 December 2024, the Hong Kong government published the Stablecoins Bill in the Gazette which aims to put in place a regulatory regime for issuers of fiat-referenced stablecoins (FRS) in Hong Kong and enhance the framework for virtual asset activities. This will be through introducing licensing requirements to certain activities related to FRS and providing the HKMA with the necessary powers for implementation of the regime. The bill will be introduced into the Legislative Council for first reading on 18 December 2024.
On 15 November 2024, the HKEX announced that their Virtual Asset Index Series is live. The virtual asset indices for bitcoin and ether provide a single reference price, enabling investors to make informed decisions in the virtual asset space. This further supports Hong Kong's development as Asia's leading digital assets hub.
On 28 November 2024, the HKMA launched the Digital Bond Grant Scheme (DBGS) which aims to promote the development of the digital securities market and encourage tokenisation in the capital markets. The DBGS allows for a maximum grant of HK$2.5 million, subject to eligibility criteria, for each digital bond issuance in Hong Kong.
The Australian Parliament has passed the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2024. The Bill, which was introduced in September 2024, makes amendments to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 in areas such as customer due diligence; governance and oversight; value transfers; and risk assessments. It also expands the regulation of virtual assets.
For more information, please see our briefings here and here.
On the 4th of December 2024, ASIC released Consultation Paper 381 Updates to INFO 225: Digital Assets: Financial Products and Services. INFO 225 Crypto-assets provides guidance to persons offering products and services in relation to crypto- and digital assets.
Consultation Paper 381 will provide further guidance on ASIC's interpretation of how the Corporations Act 2001 applies to crypto and digital assets. Consultation paper 381 also details ASIC's proposals for licensing entities that provide financial services in relation to crypto- and digital assets that are financial products.
The updates through Consultation Paper 381 are necessary to reflect the significant changes and expansion over the last 10 to 15 years in digital asset markets. Under Consultation Paper 381 the title of INFO 225 will be changed to "Digital Assets". The proposed changes in Consultation Paper 381 include:
Consultation Paper 381 also sets out (in Section B) ASIC's proposed approach to licensing digital asset businesses under the AFS licensing regime. These updates do not create new regulatory obligations and instead clarify ASIC's interpretation of existing financial services law.
Consultations on the paper close on the 28th of February 2025.
For more information, please see briefing here.
On 10 December 2024, the SEC published remarks delivered by Commissioner Hester M. Peirce at the meeting of the SEC Investor Advisory Committee. The Committee advises SEC on regulatory priorities, and on the regulation of securities products.
Peirce referred to key initiatives undertaken by the Investor Advisory Committee, including draft recommendations on the regulation of finfluencers Among other things, the draft recommends that the SEC looks at possible gaps in disclosure requirements and work with the Federal Trade Commission.
The SEC has announced that its 33rd Chair, Gary Gensler, will step down from the SEC on 20 January 2025. The SEC states that Gensler had been responsible for a robust rule making agenda, overseeing high impact enforcement cases. Gensler was formerly Chair of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, assisting the Obama Administration’s reform of the swaps market. The statement also provides an overview of Gensler's achievements in relation to corporate governance, disclosure.
The SEC published a statement from Commission Jaime Lizárraga in response to the news.
Comment: The impact of the US election is still being digested by the industry. This is a significant development that may have impact on regulatory travel and policy where it concerns digital assets.
On 4 December 2024, the House Committee on Financial Services held a Hearing titled “Innovation Revolution: How Technology is Shaping the Future of Finance". Areas covered included the regulatory framework for blockchain technology and digital sectors. The session included contributions from representatives from the Fintech industry.
On 21 November 2024, the CFTC announced that its Global Markets Advisory Committee had advanced a recommendation to expand the use of non-cash collateral through the use of DLT. The GMAC’s Digital Asset Markets Subcommittee also presented on the progress of its Utility Tokens workstream.
This recommendation contains a legal and regulatory framework on how existing policies, procedures, practices, and processes can be used to support the use of DLT for non-cash collateral in a manner consistent with margin requirements.
On 20 November 2024, the House Financial Services Committee, led by Chairman Patrick McHenry held a hearing on prudential banking regulators. In opening remarks, Chairman McHenry provided an overview of post-financial crisis regulation and cited legislative initiatives such FIT21 (see Global Digital Assets Digest May 2024 Edition). The session include contributions from federal agencies including the FDIC.
On 19 November 2024, the US Treasury published remarks by Assistant Secretary for International Finance, Brent Neiman, on the US Cross-Border Payments Agenda. Neiman argues that there is broad based consensus among stakeholders in relation to US cross-border payments agenda, calling for a modern systems of payments underpinned by strong US international financial leadership. The speech outlines key areas of action for the US in terms of payments: encouraging and participating in responsible payments innovation and experimentation; coordinating with the private sector and foreign partners to better align legal, regulatory, and supervisory frameworks; supporting strong international standards and high-quality compliance regimes to ensure the stability of payments and of the broader financial system.
Notable points
The SEC has published its FY 2024 Agency Financial Report. This provides an overview of activities of key divisions and offices of SEC, including the Division of Investment Management.
No new entries.
Contributors: Max Williams; Sasha Sawant; Anna He; Anson Chan
The information provided is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all developments in the law and practice, or to cover all aspects of those referred to.
Readers should take legal advice before applying it to specific issues or transactions.